In short
- If your car starts badly, the cause can be the battery, loose or dirty battery terminals or the alternator, the part that recharges the battery while the engine runs.
- Measure the voltage twice: with the engine off and with the engine running. With the engine running, it should be roughly between 13.0 and 14.5 volts. In cars with smart charging it can sometimes be lower.
- If the voltage stays clearly lower with the engine running, the alternator may not be charging properly, or something is wrong with the wiring. If it is only low with the engine off and fine with the engine running, the battery is the more likely cause.
- This is an indication. You only know for sure with a test at a garage.
Battery and alternator: who does what
The battery supplies the power to start the engine. Once the engine runs, the alternator takes over. The alternator is a small generator driven by the engine, usually with a belt. It supplies power for the lights, the wipers and everything else, and recharges the battery.
If the alternator stops charging, the car takes its power from the battery. The battery then slowly goes flat: lights and wipers work worse and worse, and in the end the car no longer starts. That is why a broken alternator can at first look like a flat battery.
How you notice it
- The battery warning light comes on when you switch on the ignition and should go out after starting. If it stays on or comes on while driving, something may be wrong with the charging: with the alternator, the cables or the belt that drives the alternator. Stop in a safe place and ask your breakdown service for advice.
- Your lights are dimmer or your wipers are slower. The alternator can be the cause.
- The engine starts slowly or not at all. Possible causes are a flat battery, loose or dirty connections at the battery and a broken alternator.
- You mostly drive short trips or the car stands still for a long time. Then the battery gets no chance to charge fully, even if the alternator is fine.
- If starting gets harder and harder, the battery may be worn out. A battery lasts about three to six years, sometimes longer.
How to measure it
- You need a dongle for the OBD port. That is a socket in your car where the garage connects its equipment. It is usually under the dashboard, within reach of the driver. The dongle sends the measurements to your phone. A voltmeter on the battery terminals works too.
- Measurement 1, engine off: switch on the ignition, but do not start. If you have just driven, the battery seems fuller than it is. So preferably measure after the car has stood still overnight, or first switch on the headlights for 30 seconds with the engine off.
- Measurement 2, engine running: start the engine and let it idle, so without pressing the accelerator. Watch the voltage for a minute.
- Compare your numbers with the table below.
What the numbers mean
Note: many newer cars charge smartly. The car then controls the alternator itself to save fuel. When accelerating, the alternator charges less or briefly not at all. The voltage can then drop to about 12.5 to 12.8 V. When braking and coasting, it charges harder and the voltage can rise, also above 14.5 V. Such cars also often do not charge the battery completely, with a lower charging voltage.
That is why one measurement says little. Look at what the voltage does over a few minutes. Your garage knows what is normal for your car.
- Engine off, 12.6 V (volts) or more: the battery is full.
- Engine off, between 12.0 and 12.6 V: the battery is not completely full. That can happen after many short trips.
- Engine off, below 12 V: the battery is flat, is not being charged properly or there is a bad connection.
- Engine running, between 13.0 and 14.5 V: the alternator is charging.
- Engine running, below about 13.2 V and it stays that way: that can point to a broken alternator or to bad wiring and connections.
- Engine running, above 14.5 V: that can point to a broken voltage regulator (the part that controls the alternator), a bad battery or bad connections.
What Car-Z does and does not see
- Everyone gets a warning when the voltage drops below 12.6 V with the engine running: then the alternator does not seem to be charging. In a car with smart charging, the voltage can also briefly get that low while nothing is wrong. If the warning keeps coming back or stays on, have it checked.
- Without an account you see the engine speed and the vehicle speed live. With a free account you also see the battery voltage and the coolant temperature live.
- With Plus you do the starting and charging test. It measures the voltage with the engine off, the lowest point while starting and the charging voltage at idle and at slightly higher revs.
- If your car has stored a fault code, such as P0562 (system voltage low), Car-Z reads it and explains it.
- Car-Z measures the voltage through the dongle at the OBD port, not at the battery itself. That measurement can differ by a few tenths of a volt from a good voltmeter on the battery. Car-Z also does not measure how much current the battery can deliver in the cold (CCA). Car-Z does not make a diagnosis: it shows what the car reports and what the dongle measures. A garage makes the diagnosis.
Frequently asked questions
My car won't start. Is it the battery or the alternator?
You can only tell once the engine is running again, for example after your breakdown service has got it going. Low with the engine off and fine (13.0 to 14.5 V) with the engine running: then the alternator is charging and the cause is more likely the battery, the connections or short trips. If the voltage stays low with the engine running, the alternator may not be charging or something is wrong with the wiring. Have it checked by a garage or your breakdown service.
Can a new battery fix the problem if the alternator is broken?
No. A new battery is then not recharged and goes flat again after a while. So measure with the engine running first, before you buy a battery.
My phone shows 12.6 V while the engine is running. Is my alternator broken?
Not necessarily. In cars with smart charging, the alternator sometimes briefly charges less or not at all, for example when the battery is full enough. Watch the voltage for a few minutes. If the voltage stays low or the battery warning light comes on, have it checked.
Can I check the alternator belt myself?
You can look: with the engine off and cooled down, you can see whether the belt is still in place and whether it has cracks or frayed edges. If you see those, it needs to be replaced. On a modern car, that is better left to a garage.
Sources
- Charging System DiagnosisDENSO Auto Parts, consulted on 18 November 2026
- Battery Visual Inspection & Performance Testing for Starters & AlternatorsDENSO Auto Parts, consulted on 18 November 2026
- Regulating an alternator: functions, diagnostics and tips for the workshopHELLA TECH WORLD, consulted on 18 November 2026
- Smart Charging & Load Management (ASE A6 study guide)Open Exam Prep, consulted on 18 November 2026
- Dynamo (alternator)ANWB, consulted on 18 November 2026
- V-snaar of multiriem (V-belt or multi-rib belt)ANWB, consulted on 18 November 2026
- Waarschuwingslampjes (warning lights: the battery warning light)ANWB, consulted on 18 November 2026
- Hoe werkt een accu en wanneer moet je je accu vervangen? (how a battery works and when to replace it)ANWB, consulted on 18 November 2026
- 8 Signs Of A Bad Alternator Vs Bad BatteryAAA Club Alliance, consulted on 18 November 2026
- Startmotor, opsporen van storingen (starter motor troubleshooting, technical information, 2005)Hella, consulted on 18 November 2026
- How do you measure battery voltage? (surface charge)OPTIMA Batteries, consulted on 18 November 2026
- ELM327 datasheet, RV and CV (accuracy of the voltage measurement, about 2%)Elm Electronics, consulted on 18 November 2026
- On-board diagnostics (OBD-II connector within 2 ft of the steering wheel)Wikipedia, consulted on 18 November 2026
- Where is the OBD2 port? (general location, within 60 cm of the steering wheel)Klavkarr (photos from users), consulted on 18 November 2026